Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Newsroom diversity

I ran across this interesting article from the AP regarding religious diversity among publications.

The article talks about evangelical Christians and how they are historically under-represented in the media. You hear lots of exagerated talk about the "big, bad liberal media" among a lot of conservatives, and they often point to the lack of religious diversity in the newsroom as the reason.

The article told of Christian journalists leaving the field to work for religious publications instead. "While there's been heavy gender and racial diversity ... there's a lack of cultural diversity in journalism," said Terry Mattingly, director of the Washington Journalism Center.

Religion is in the definite minority in the newsroom. The Pew Research Center for the People and Press conducted an interesting survey. Only 8% of journalists attended regular religious services. 68% of journalists either never attended religious services or only attended a few times a year.

This is in stark contrast to the general public. 39% of people attend religious services on a weekly basis.

Robert Case, of the World Journalism Institute, made it clear that evangelicals are often grouped into a "sterotype." However, they "are diverse politically, intellectually and theologically," even though this diversity among Christians is often overshadowed.

"It bothers me that when mainstream outlets want an evangelical voice, they've turned to Jerry Falwell or James Dobson or Pat Robertson," Case said. "They are men of high regard and standing, but there are others who have a different take on things."

This article was particularly of interest to me, because I am of the evangelical faith. I do think that journalism is and should always remain open and un-biased. However, I think diversity in the newsroom should at least equal diversity in society. And I don't just mean Christians. I mean other people of faith as well.

I think there are definite places for religious slant in writing, such as in faith-based publications. But obviously, I do not support more Christians in the mainstream newsroom just to "take it over" and impose their agenda. We want as little bias as possible, and that definitely includes religious biases.

I do think, however, that Christians shouldn't be so afraid or resentful of the media, and I believe they should go out there and work in the mainstream media. Hopefully, these journalists will realize the great asset they have - the ability to write about and cover religion with in-depth understanding and first-hand knowledge of faith-based communities and how they operate.

The article summed up the goal of evangelicals in journalism:

In seeking a greater voice in the media, most evangelical leaders say their goal isn't to evangelize inside newsrooms, which demand that journalists set aside their beliefs for the sake of objectivity.

"They have to be journalists first," Mattingly said. "You don't need more Christian journalists. You need more journalists who happen to be Christians if they're going to contribute to any real diversity in newsrooms."

So what do you all think? Does the media seem inclusive and diverse? Or should more faiths be represented in the newsroom?

6 comments:

Mrs.prettyweather said...

You have a really good point. The news room definitely shouldn't be a biased place. I think that those who have religious views should open up to their GIFT and understanding of religion.There ideas could be a necessity in alot of publications.

cannse3 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
cannse3 said...

I think that it is unfair that the news can choose to be bias. I mean I am all for freedom of speech, etc but when the media and its networks are responsible for what people see and believe is going on around the world, I believe it should be strictly facts not opinions.

Shannon said...

I never noticed before, there are not very many evangelical Christians in media. I think the media should be diverse as possible, but maybe the reason why there are not many is because others will see them as biased. I am not saying that all news is completely fair all the time but I think when it comes to religion others can get a little nervous. If about 40% of the public honestly does attend Christian church regularly, there is definitely an audience, one that needs to be looked into.

I do agree with Terry Mattingly, "You don't need more Christian journalists. You need more journalists who happen to be Christians if they're going to contribute to any real diversity in newsrooms."

There may be more Christians in media than we think. Christians could be possibly shy of announcing their faith to invite more of a general audience to their news medium.
On the other hand, I know most Christians were taught to follow Matthew 10:33.

Why stop at Christians? Why not Jewish journalists, or Mormons, or Buddhists and etc.?

Anonymous said...

I can't say I want more religious voice in the newsroom. It should be like politics; keep them separate. Besides the fact that your creed has no influence on the facts of a news story, it could also lead to people having biases towards certain media outlets.

Ramen Ninja said...

I think that people tend to forget that everyone is an individual and that there will always be personal differences, opinions, religious views, political views, etc within the group of journalists that serve in the mass media.

The fact that someone is a Christian is not much different from the fact that someone may be a Democrat. There are going to be things that influence the opinions of people within both groups, but that does not mean that these people are incapable of reporting news without bias.

Whether you are a Christian journalist or not shouldn't matter to news publications, what should matter is whether or not you are going to stick to the ethics of journalism.